The Bircher Bar is proudly reader-supported! When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Click to learn more.

The 8 Best Protein Powders Currently in the Market

a woman mixing protein powder in a shaker

Key Takeaways

  • From athletes to health-conscious individuals, protein powders cater to various needs, including muscle growth, weight management, and dietary preferences.
  • Selection based on protein type, amino acid profile, taste, brand reputation, and special dietary needs ensures the best fit for individual goals.
  • The guide highlights the best protein powders in the market, including options for weight loss, plant-based diets, high protein content, taste, and value.
  • Studies support the role of protein in muscle synthesis, weight control, performance enhancement, and immune function.
  • Awareness of potential digestive issues, allergies, or overconsumption risks helps in making informed choices.
  • Protein powders can be consumed in various ways, from shakes to recipes, aligning with personal preferences.
  • Understanding the types, benefits, and best practices in using protein powders can transform them into a targeted health strategy.

Whether you're an athlete or someone simply looking to boost your daily protein intake, the right protein powder can be a game-changer.

Protein is a vital nutrient that plays a key role in virtually everything the body does. It's essential for muscle growth, tissue repair, and many other bodily functions.

Even if you eat meat and other protein-rich foods, most of us will benefit greatly from supplementing additional protein in our diets. But with the shelves (and ‘internet shelves’) brimming with protein powder options, how do you pick the best one?

Well, don't worry, we've done the heavy lifting for you.

From quality ingredients to taste, from affordability to nutritional value, we've tested, researched and examined countless brands and styles. In this comprehensive guide, you'll find what we believe are currently the best protein powders to suit a range of different budgets, diets and needs.

Let's go!

Our Top Picks for the Best Protein Powders This Year

1.) White Wolf Vegan All-In-One Pea Protein

White Wolf Vegan All-In-One Pea Protein

Key Features:

  • Protein Type: Vegan Pea Protein
  • Organic Superfood Blend: Includes Australian Organic Blueberry, Raspberry powder and Acai.
  • Relatively High Protein: 22.1g of protein per 30g serve
  • No Artificial Additives: No added sugars, colours, or preservatives.

What Sets It Apart:

White Wolf Vegan All-In-One Pea Protein is distinguished by its organic superfood blend which includes a number of different nutritional powerhouses such as Australian organic blueberry, raspberry powder, acai, flaxseed, coconut, poppy seeds and more.

The 100% natural formulation ensures maximum bio-availability and easy digestion without any of the dodgy additives that many other brands pack in. This protein blend is not just about muscle recovery but overall well-being, making it a top choice for health-conscious individuals.

You can learn more with our full review of the White Wolf Vegan All-In-One Pea Protein.


  • Vegan friendly
  • High in fibre
  • 100% Natural
  • No added gluten
  • Rich in superfoods


  • Slightly grainy texture
  • Higher price point
  • May not be suitable for those with nut allergies (made on a production line with nuts)

Product Details:

  • Price: $$
  • Serving Size: 30g per serving, 22.1g of protein per serving
  • Money Back Guarantee: 30 days replace or refund for any broken, damaged or incorrect items
Click here to check the latest prices on White Wolf Nutrition All-In-One Pea Protein

2.) True Protein WPI90 Whey Protein Isolate

True Protein WPI90 Whey Protein Isolate

Key Features:

  • Protein Type: Whey protein isolate boasts over 90% protein content.
  • Fast Digesting: Ideal for post-workout recovery.
  • Low in Lactose: Suitable for those with lactose sensitivity.
  • Less Than 1% Carbs & Sugar: Perfect for low-carb diets.
  • Rich Amino Acid Profile: Supports muscles and provides vital nutrition.

What Sets It Apart:

True Protein’s WPI90 is a top-tier product sourced from New Zealand and known for its high protein content and purity.

Its unique manufacturing process uses both cross-flow microfiltration (MF) and ultrafiltration (UF) to develop a refined protein powder that's tasty and easy on the gut.

Suitable for vegetarians and gluten-free, it's a favourite amongst athletes (both amateurs and professionals)

If you want to know a bit more about this one - we dive deeper in our full review of the True Protein WPI Whey Protein Isolate.


  • Manufactured in third-party certified facilities
  • Low in carbs and added sugars
  • Gluten-free
  • Halal-friendly
  • HASTA WPI 90 certified option


  • Somewhat pricey
  • No third-party testing seal
  • Not suitable for vegan diets

Product Details:

  • Price: $$
  • Serving Size: 30g per serving, 24g of protein per serving
  • Money Back Guarantee: Yes, within 14 days
 Click here to check the latest prices on True Protein WPI90 Whey

3.) Momentous Essential Plant-Based Protein

Momentous Essential Plant-Based Protein

Key Features:

  • Protein Type: Plant-Based Protein (70:30 blend of pea and rice proteins)
  • Complete Amino Acid Profile: Provides all nine essential amino acids.
  • Supports Muscle Growth and Recovery: High leucine content from peas helps support muscle repair.
  • Easy-to-Mix Powder: Dissolves easily into food and drinks.
  • Naturally Sweetened: With organic cane sugar.

What Sets It Apart:

Momentous Essential Plant-Based Protein stands out for its unique blend of pea and rice proteins, creating a complete amino acid profile that rivals traditional whey proteins.

Its 70:30 ratio ensures a high leucine content, vital for muscle repair, making it a great choice for athletes and fitness enthusiasts. The natural sweetness from organic cane sugar, coupled with its easy-to-mix texture, offers a pleasant taste without the chalkiness often found in plant-based options.

Designed for optimal absorption, it's a versatile and effective solution for those seeking a dairy-free alternative without compromising on quality and taste.


  • 3rd party testing: NSF-certified sport & Informed sport
  • High leucine content
  • Naturally sweetened, avoiding artificial flavours
  • Suitable for those lactose-intolerant
  • Designed for optimal absorption


  • Pricier than some other options
  • Limited flavour options
  • Not as high a protein content per serving as whey protein

Product Details:

  • Price: $$
  • Serving Size: 37.7g per serving, 20g protein per serving
  • Money Back Guarantee: Yes, within 30 days

4.) Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder

Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder

Key Features:

  • Protein Type: Whey Protein (Blend of whey protein isolates, concentrate, and peptides)
  • Complete Amino Acid Profile: For optimal muscle growth and repair.
  • Gluten-Free: Suitable for those with gluten sensitivity.
  • Banned Substance Tested: Ensures purity and quality.

What Sets It Apart:

Optimum Nutrition is one of the world’s most highly rated sports supplement brands with their Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder amassing over 200,000 reviews on Amazon for an average of 4.7 stars.

This particular product stands out for its blend of high-quality whey protein - which includes a mix of isolates, concentrate, and peptides. This combination ensures a rapid and steady release of amino acids, fueling muscles and aiding in recovery.

With over 20 unique flavours, it offers variety without compromising on taste or quality and furthermore, thier commitment to transparent quality testing further solidifies its position as a top choice among fitness enthusiasts.


  • Wide range of flavours
  • Affordable
  • No artificial growth hormones
  • Tested for banned substances via 3rd party labs


  • Not lactose-free (contains digestive enzymes)
  • Has artificial sweeteners
  • Some flavours may be too sweet for some tastes

Product Details:

  • Price: $
  • Serving Size: 31g per serving, 24g of Protein per Serving
  • Money Back Guarantee: Not specified

5.) Hemp Foods Organic Hemp Gold Protein

Hemp Foods Organic Hemp Gold Protein

Key Features:

  • Protein Type: Hemp Protein (60% Protein)
  • Complete Amino Acid Profile: Supports muscle growth and digestion.
  • Gut Friendly: Grain-free protein with a creamy texture.
  • Australian Made: Always supports local farmers when possible.

What Sets It Apart:

Hemp Foods Organic Hemp Gold Protein is a natural plant-based protein that stands out for its fine texture and easy digestibility. Made using a purely mechanical cold-milling process, it ensures a quality extraction without the use of chemicals.

Its complete amino acid profile and creamy texture make it a preferred choice for those looking for a guilt-free energy boost. Supporting local farmers and providing a grain-free protein option, this product offers a unique, effective and ethical choice in the protein market.


  • Vegan Friendly
  • GMO-free
  • Affordable
  • Easy to mix
  • Rich in Omega fatty acids and antioxidants
  • Supports Australian farmers


  • Limited flavour options
  • Not a super high-protein content
  • Some may find the taste too mild or nutty

Product Details:

  • Price: $
  • Serving Size: 33g per serving, 21.3g protein per serving
  • Money Back Guarantee: Yes, within 30 days

6.) Musashi High Protein Powder

Musashi High Protein Powder

Key Features:

  • Protein Type: Blend of Whey Protein Concentrate, Whey Protein Isolate, and Milk Protein Solids
  • High Protein Content: 30 grams of quality protein per serve
  • Informed Sport Certified: 3rd party tested for quality and safety.

What Sets It Apart:

Musashi High Protein Powder is scientifically formulated to support muscle recovery with a blend of quality protein sources, including Whey Protein Concentrate, Isolate, and Milk Protein Solids.

What sets it apart is its commitment to quality, offering a versatile supplement for various training goals. With a reputation for great taste and consistency, as well as being Informed-Sport Certified, it's a reliable choice for athletes and fitness enthusiasts who demand both flavour and performance in their protein supplement.


  • Mixes well
  • High protein content
  • Informed sport certified
  • Batch tested for consistency


  • Only 3 flavour options
  • Not suitable for lactose-intolerant individuals
  • Contains some artificial sweeteners and additives

Product Details:

  • Price: $
  • Serving Size: 45g per serving, 30g protein per serving
  • Money Back Guarantee: Yes, within 30 days for damaged or faulty items

7.) Sunwarrior Blend Organic Clean Vegan Protein

Sunwarrior Blend Organic Clean Vegan Protein

Key Features:

  • Protein Type: Blend of Organic Pea Protein, Organic Goji Berry, Organic Hemp Seed Protein
  • Low Calorie & Carb: Only 90 calories and less than 1g of carbs per serving
  • Vegan & Keto-Friendly: Suitable for various dietary preferences
  • Superfoods & Nutrients: Contains 4 superfoods and plant-based ingredients
  • Gluten-Free, Non-GMO, Soy-Free: Clean and natural formulation

What Sets It Apart:

Sunwarrior Vegan Protein is notable for its blend of organic superfoods and nutrients, including Organic Pea Protein, Goji Berry, and Hemp Seed Protein. With only 90 calories and less than 1g of carbs, it's designed to help boost the metabolism and burn fat.

Its vegan and keto-friendly formulation, combined with a commitment to quality and taste, makes it a unique choice for those seeking a natural plant-based protein powder option. The product's heavy metal testing ensures safety, and its climate pledge adds an eco-friendly aspect.


  • Vegan and keto-friendly
  • Contains BCAAs for fast absorption
  • No added sugars or artificial colours


  • Not as easy to mix as some others

Product Details:

  • Price: $
  • Serving Size: 25g per serving, 17g of Protein per Serving
  • Money Back Guarantee: Yes, within 30 days

8.) Tropeaka Lean Protein

Tropeaka Lean Protein

Key Features:

  • Protein Type: Blend of Pea Protein Isolate, Sprouted Brown Rice Protein, and Pumpkin Seed Protein
  • Natural Ingredients: No artificial flavours or sweeteners
  • Digestive Enzymes: Easily digestible and non-bloating
  • Vegan-Friendly: Suitable for vegetarians and vegans

What Sets It Apart:

Tropeaka Lean Protein is a combination of organic plant-based proteins designed to provide all of the necessary amino acids for muscle repair and building. All of their products, including this one, are nutritionist and naturopath-certified.

Its free from artificial flavours and sweeteners with a full 5-star health rating (Australian Government initiative) and USDA organic certification. Furthermore, it contains a range of different herbs and superfoods to round out it’s nutritional profile and add a great flavour base.


  • High in branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs)
  • Contains naturally occurring antioxidants
  • Low in saturated fat and carbohydrates
  • 5 Star health rating


  • Lower protein content per serving than whey varieties
  • May not blend well with just a shaker bottle

Product Details:

  • Price: $
  • Serving Size: 25g per serving, 17.4g of Protein per Serving
  • Money Back Guarantee: Not specified

How We Chose Our Best Picks

In putting together our selection of the best protein powder we’ve tried, we looked at a number of factors and variables that might appeal to anyone looking to make a purchase:

  • Firstly - our own experience: Did we personally enjoy it?
  • Protein Type: We evaluated the source of protein, such as whey, plant-based, or casein, to cater to different dietary needs.
  • Amino Acid Profile: A complete amino acid profile ensures optimal muscle growth and repair.
  • Taste and Flavour Options: Taste tests and flavour variety were considered to suit different palates.
  • Price and Brand Reputation: We looked at the cost-effectiveness and trustworthiness of the brands.
  • Customer Reviews: Real user feedback provided insights into the product's effectiveness and satisfaction.
  • Special Dietary Needs: Gluten-free, vegan-friendly, banned substance tested, and other unique features were assessed.
  • Artificial Ingredients and Sweeteners: We prioritized products with minimal artificial additives.
  • Third-Party Testing: Products with quality testing ensured purity and safety. We also favoured products certified to be safe for competitive athletes, adhering to industry best practices.
  • Health Claims: We ensured that the products did not make exaggerated or false health claims. Any assertions made were in alignment with our approach to well-being.

Best Brands for Specific Needs:

Best for Weight Loss: True Protein WPI90

True Protein WPI90 stands out as the best protein powder for weight loss, offering 25.8 grams of protein for just 114 calories per serving. Its blend of high-quality whey isolate protein ensures a rapid release of amino acids, aiding in muscle recovery and growth, without any significant carbohydrate of fat content.

Best Pea Protein: Momentous Essential Plant-Based Protein

Momentous Essential Plant-Based Protein is the top choice for pea protein, offering a complete profile of all nine essential amino acids. Other than the 70:30 blend of pea and rice proteins, its high leucine content, derived from peas, supports muscle growth, and the taste is praised for not having the typical chalky plant protein flavour.

Best Hemp Protein: Hemp Foods Organic Hemp Gold Protein

Hemp Foods Organic Hemp Gold Protein offers a complete amino acid profile with 60% protein content. It's made with Hemp Gold™, providing an easy-to-digest, grain-free protein powder that's also vegan-friendly. Its fine texture and creamy taste make it a top choice for hemp protein.

Best High-Protein Content: Musashi High-Protein Powder

Musashi High Protein Powder is scientifically formulated to be high in protein, delivering 30 grams of protein per serving. Combining Whey Protein Concentrate, Whey Isolate, and Milk Protein Solids, it's the best option for those seeking to build muscle with a high-protein supplement.

Best in Value: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey

Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder stands out as the best value and most affordable option. With 27 servings per container and 24g of protein per 31g serving, it offers a substantial amount of protein in each serving. This makes it an efficient and effective choice for those seeking quality protein without compromising on cost. Its reputation for quality and balanced nutritional profile further solidifies its position as a top choice for value-conscious fitness enthusiasts.

Best Vegan: Sunwarrior Blend Organic Clean Vegan Protein

Sunwarrior Vegan Protein is a standout choice for those seeking the best vegan protein powder option. What sets it apart is its unique blend of 4 superfoods, nutrients, and plant-based ingredients, including Organic Pea Protein, Organic Goji Berry, and Organic Hemp Seed Protein. It's not just about the protein content; it's also about the commitment to clean, organic, and sustainable ingredients. The product is climate pledge friendly, reflecting a responsible approach to environmental stewardship.

Best Tasting: Tropeaka Lean Protein

For most users - Tropeaka Lean Protein takes the crown for the best-tasting protein powder. What distinguishes it from others is its popularity in regular flavours like vanilla, salted caramel, chocolate, and more, as well as seasonal flavours like gingerbread and strawberry cream. Users have praised its pleasant sweetness, achieved with natural sweeteners, without being overly sweet.

Benefits of Protein Powders

Protein powders offer a wide array of advantages for various individuals. For athletes and bodybuilders, they are essential for muscle growth and repair. According to a study, protein aids in muscle synthesis and recovery, making it a vital component of a fitness regimen.

For those looking to manage their weight, protein's role in promoting satiety can be a powerful solution. A number of studies now highlight how protein intake can support weight loss or maintenance efforts by increasing feelings of fullness. Consuming enough protein can lead to reduced calorie intake, aiding in weight control.

The convenience of protein powders makes them ideal for busy lifestyles, providing a quick nutritional boost when needed. Some blends even include additional nutrients that enhance performance by boosting energy and endurance. This particular study on endurance athletes found that protein supplementation could improve performance and recovery.

With options catering to different dietary needs, such as gluten-free or vegan, protein powders offer inclusive solutions for everyone. For those following a plant-based diet, a research paper emphasizes the importance of plant-based proteins in providing essential amino acids.

Moreover, protein powders can be beneficial for older adults. A study found that protein supplementation could enhance muscle mass and strength in elderly individuals, supporting overall health and well-being.

Lastly, protein's role in immune function has been explored in various studies, including this one, which highlights how protein can support the immune system, particularly in athletes who may be at risk of immune suppression due to intense training.

Side Effects of Protein Powders

While protein powders are beneficial for many, they may also have some side effects.

Digestive issues can occur, particularly with ingredients like lactose, which may cause bloating or gas in sensitive individuals.

Allergic reactions are another concern, and careful selection is needed for those with allergies to specific ingredients like dairy or soy.

Overconsumption of protein can lead to potential risks such as kidney strain or nutrient imbalances, so monitoring intake is essential.

These side effects are generally very rare, however, it's always advisable to consult with healthcare providers or nutritionists to ensure that the chosen protein powder aligns with individual health needs and goals.

When Is the Best Time to Take Protein Powder?

a man weightlifting in the gym

The ideal time to consume protein powder can vary based on personal goals and preferences.

For muscle growth and recovery, taking protein immediately after a workout can be beneficial. This post-workout window is when muscles are most receptive to nutrients, and protein can aid in recovery and growth.

For those using protein as a general dietary supplement or to help control hunger, consuming it between meals or as a snack can be effective. Some even prefer to take protein before bed to support overnight muscle repair.

Who Should Not Take It

Protein powders may not be suitable for:

  • Kidney Disorders: Those with kidney issues should consult healthcare providers.
  • Allergies: Careful selection is needed to avoid allergenic ingredients.
  • Pregnant or Nursing Women: Professional guidance is recommended to ensure safety.

Best Ways to Use Protein Powder

Protein powder is versatile and can be consumed in various ways.

The most common method is to mix it with water, milk, or a milk alternative to create a protein shake. Blending it with fruits, vegetables, and other ingredients can create nutritious smoothies.

Protein powder can also be added to recipes like pancakes, muffins, or oatmeal to enhance the protein content. Some prefer to take it with their coffee or tea.

The key is to follow the manufacturer's instructions for the recommended serving size and to choose a method that aligns with taste preferences and dietary needs.

Experimenting with different flavours and combinations can make consuming protein powder an enjoyable part of a healthy diet.

TheDifferent Types of Protein Powders:

Whey Protein

A very popular choice, whey protein offers fast absorption, rich amino acids, and supports muscle growth. It's derived from milk, so lactose-intolerant individuals should be cautious. Whey protein is often used for post-workout recovery due to its rapid digestion and absorption.

Plant-Based Protein

A diverse category, plant-based proteins like peas, hemp, or rice cater to vegans and those avoiding animal products. They offer unique nutrient profiles and are generally easy to digest. Pea protein, for example, is rich in essential amino acids and is a great alternative for those with dairy allergies. Hemp protein is known for its omega-3 fatty acids content, and rice protein is often combined with pea protein to create a complete amino acid profile.

Casein Protein

Casein provides a slow release of amino acids, making it suitable for nighttime consumption or prolonged nourishment. It's also derived from milk. Unlike whey, casein forms a gel in the stomach, leading to a slow, steady release of amino acids. This makes it an excellent choice for sustained protein delivery, especially during periods of fasting like sleep.

Collagen Protein

Collagen protein is derived from animal connective tissues and is known for supporting skin, hair, and joint health. It's not a complete protein, as it lacks some essential amino acids, but it's a popular supplement for those looking to improve skin elasticity and joint function.

Egg White Protein

Egg white protein is made from the whites of eggs and is a complete protein source, meaning it contains all the essential amino acids. It's low in fat and carbohydrates, making it a popular choice for those focusing on lean muscle gain.

Soy Protein

Soy protein is a complete plant-based protein derived from soybeans. It's a versatile option that can be used in various dietary applications, including vegetarian and vegan diets.

Brown Rice Protein

Brown rice protein is derived from whole-grain brown rice. While it's not a complete protein on its own, it's often combined with other plant proteins to provide a balanced amino acid profile. It's a good option for those looking for a plant-based, gluten-free protein source.

Hemp Protein

Hemp protein is made from the seeds of the hemp plant and is known for its omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids content. While not a complete protein, it's a good source of fibre and healthy fats, making it a nutritious addition to a balanced diet.

How to Choose the Right High-Quality Protein Powder

Considerations include:

  • Dietary Needs: Align with personal dietary restrictions or preferences.
  • Fitness Goals: Select based on desired outcomes like muscle gain or weight loss.
  • Amount of protein per serving: Select based on your daily protein needs for muscle growth, recovery, or general health.
  • Taste Preferences: Sample different flavours to find favourites.
  • Budget: Consider cost per serving and overall value.


Q1: How much protein do I need daily?

Individual needs vary widely with factors such as activity levels, gender and age having a big impact on protein needs. The guidance for this also varies between practiioners, however, according to the highly respected Dr. Peter Attia - most adults should aim for around 2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight (or about 1 gram per pound) per day.

Q2: Is it safe to consume protein powder every day?

Yes, it is generally safe to consume protein powder every day as part of a balanced diet. According to this review, daily protein supplementation is considered safe for healthy individuals, provided it does not exceed the recommended dietary allowance of 56 grams for men and 46 grams for women per day.

Q3: How do I choose the healthiest protein powder?

Choose a protein powder with natural ingredients, no artificial additives, and a complete amino acid profile. Consider dietary needs, such as vegan or gluten-free, and look for third-party testing for quality assurance.

Q4: How good is protein powder after the expiration date?

Using protein powder after the expiration date may lead to a decrease in potency and flavour. While it might not be harmful if stored properly, it's best to adhere to the expiration date for optimal quality and effectiveness.

Closing Thoughts

Protein powders have evolved to become accessible and versatile nutritional supplements. They cater to a wide array of dietary needs and preferences, bridging gaps and enhancing nutritional intake. But their value goes beyond mere convenience.

Understanding the types, benefits, and best practices in using protein powders can transform them from a simple supplement into a targeted health strategy.

Remember, it's not just about the product itself but how you integrate it into your lifestyle. Make informed choices, align them with your goals, and let protein powders enhance your pursuit of a healthier you.

Darcy Ogdon-Nolan

Holding a Bachelor Of Science (Hons.) combined with close to a decade now in the health food and wellness industry, I believe I'm uniquely positioned to provide a depth of knowledge and first-hand experience on emerging health products, trends and ideas! From greens powders and medicinal mushrooms through to protein powders and workout nutrition - I'm particularly interested in what modern science can uncover about what human cultures have been using to treat ailments for millennia!

Related Posts

Maca Root Side Effects (Plus Health Benefits and Dosage)
Maca Root Side Effects (Plus Health Benefits and Dosage)
Key Takeaways Side Effects: Digestive issues, hormonal changes, menstrual cycle changes, sleep disruptions, allergi...
Read More
Magnesium Threonate vs Glycinate: A Detailed Guide for 2024
Magnesium Threonate vs Glycinate: A Detailed Guide for 2024
Key Takeaways Magnesium L-threonate and glycinate serve different health purposes, with threonate targeting cognitiv...
Read More
Green Juice Benefits: Why You Should Drink Green Juice
Green Juice Benefits: Why You Should Drink Green Juice
Key Takeaways Packed with Power: Get your daily dose of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants in a delicious glass. ...
Read More

The Bircher Bar's Top Product List:

We are always trialling and testing the best science-backed stuff we can find to help support and improve our health, performance and lonegvity!

The list below showcases some of our favourite finds in some key areas of health and happiness - check them out:

1.) For Covering Nutritional Bases & Supporting Energy

Athletic Greens AG1

Check Product: Athletic Greens AG1

(Or Click Here To Read Our Full Review)

2.) For Optimising Sleep Quality & Duration

Momentous Huberman Lab Sleep Bundle

3.) For Supporting Good Digestion & Gut Health

(Or Click Here To Read Our Full Review)

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published